❌ Was Nemanja Matić right? Andre Onana as 'one of the worst' goalkeepers in Manchester United history – ranking of the biggest disappointments in goal for the Red Devils

Andre Onana is under fire again after making two costly mistakes against Lyon in the Europa League quarter-finals. But does he really deserve to be called United’s worst goalkeeper of the Premier League era ? Let’s see how he compares to other goalkeepers who have failed at Old Trafford.

🧨 Lyon's mistakes and Maticia's words

Ahead of the match against Lyon, Onana put pressure on himself, saying that “United are much better” than the French team. The response was not long in coming – Nemanja Matić called him “one of the worst goalkeepers in the club’s history” .

The Cameron could have responded with a good game. Instead... he made more mistakes. He let in a trivial free-kick from Almada, then deflected a simple shot into the feet of Rayan Cherki, who equalised. It was Onana's eighth mistake that led directly to a goal - the most in the Premier League since his transfer.

🧱 Ranking – Manchester United's Biggest Goalkeeping Disappointments

8. Ben Foster
He was supposed to be England's number one at United. He failed in key games against Arsenal and City. After van der Sar returned, he disappeared.

7. Mark Bosnich
Ferguson called him a “terrible professional.” Chronically late, overeating, out of shape. Left after testing positive for cocaine.

6. Tim Howard
He started well, but a dramatic mistake against Porto and a subsequent fight with Carroll ended his career at Old Trafford.

5. Roy Carroll
He didn’t save the team in important moments. He became famous for his “invisible goal” after a shot by Pedro Mendes crossed the line – but it was disallowed.

4. Fabien Barthez
The crazy world champion. We remember his terrible matches against Arsenal and Deportivo. He tried to cheat Di Canio... but he made a fool of himself.

3. Victor Valdes
He played only twice. He was rejected by van Gaal, who accused him of lack of discipline and unwillingness to play for the reserves.

2. Massimo Taibi
11 goals conceded in 4 matches. The worst of them – Le Tissier’s easy shot between the legs. Nickname: “The Blind Venetian”.

1. Andre Onana
He was supposed to be the solution, but he's a disaster. He makes more mistakes than he brings. United paid £47m, ignored De Gea... and Onana makes a fool of himself on a regular basis. Without a doubt - the biggest disappointment in goal in the club's history.